BYU or AUR?

I have been accepted to both Brigham Young University and the American University of Rome. They are kind of opposites when it comes to college - AUR in big city, no religous affiliation, small student body, extremely far away from home, somewhat expensive. BYU in small city, LDS affiliation, huge student body, pretty close to home, less expensive. I want to major in Art History, and BYU's program is really good - but Art History in Rome, would be amazing!!! I have a pretty good scholarship to BYU and AUR is pretty expensive, so that is the big drawback. I am just really torn between the two, and would love anyone's input!